February 25 News: The debate over whether XRP Ledger (XRPL) is a centralized blockchain has quickly heated up in the crypto community. Justin Bons, founder and CIO of Cyber Capital, publicly questioned the decentralization of XRPL, arguing that its reliance on the Unique Node List (UNL) mechanism essentially makes it a “permissioned blockchain,” deviating from the true permissionless crypto network concept.
Justin Bons pointed out that XRPL validators typically refer to recommended node lists published by a central authority. Deviating from this list could lead to network forks, creating potential governance centralization risks. He also categorized XRPL alongside networks like Stellar, Hedera, and Algorand as “permissioned architectures,” emphasizing that blockchains not based on PoW or PoS consensus may be closer to an authority-based proof model (PoA), making full trust minimization difficult.
In response, Ripple’s Chief Technology Officer David Schwartz issued a positive statement, denying that Ripple has absolute control over the XRP Ledger. He explained that XRPL was designed to prevent any single entity from dominating the network, with each node independently choosing which validators to trust, rather than relying solely on official recommendations. Even if validators act dishonestly, nodes can adjust their UNL to maintain consensus security.
David Schwartz further stated that validators cannot force honest nodes to accept double-spend transactions or implement censorship. XRPL confirms transactions through consensus rounds approximately every five seconds, mechanismically reducing risks of censorship and double spending. He acknowledged that, in theory, if most validators colluded, it could impact network operation, but this is a typical majority attack issue, not a structural power Ripple controls alone.
This controversy also raises a core industry question: how should blockchain decentralization standards be defined? Some analysts believe that XRPL’s performance advantages and fast settlement capabilities stem from its unique consensus mechanism, rather than traditional PoW models. Meanwhile, as regulatory environments tighten and institutional attention increases, discussions around the security, decentralization, and governance transparency of permissioned blockchains are expected to intensify, becoming a key factor influencing the long-term narrative of the XRP ecosystem.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
XRP ETF attracts over $19 million, with AUM approaching $1.1 billion. Why does the price still hover around $1.40?
Despite XRP price pressure, investors remain interested in XRP ETFs, with approximately $19 million flowing in over the past week and total assets nearing $1.1 billion. However, XRP trading prices are still more than 60% below their all-time highs, and market sentiment remains cautious. Analysts point out that the influence of XRP ETFs is far less than that of Bitcoin ETFs. Overall, XRP's future performance is closely tied to market sentiment and Ripple's technological applications.
GateNews24m ago
XRP stabilizes at $1.40, oil prices retreat, and the CLARITY bill boosts the market
On Friday, XRP price remained stable at $1.40, driven by falling oil prices and Ripple CEO's support for the CLARITY Act. The decline in oil prices eases inflationary pressures and helps risk assets perform. The bill could boost exchange confidence, encourage institutional participation, and promote product development. XRP funding rates turned negative, indicating a concentration of short positions, and a comprehensive assessment is needed to determine the short-term trend.
MarketWhisper1h ago
Elon Musk Unveils X Money Beta, Sparking XRP Integration Speculation as Token Tests $1.50
Elon Musk has revealed the beta launch of X Money, a payment platform integrated into the X social media network, with initial interface screenshots showing features for sending and receiving funds, direct deposit, and yield-bearing accounts.
CryptopulseElite3h ago
XRP Holds $1.40 as Bitcoin Rally and ETF Inflows Lift Crypto Market
Key Insights
XRP maintained support above $1.40 as the broader market rebounded, while strong inflows into Bitcoin ETFs helped restore trading confidence.
Bitcoin surged beyond $74,000 alongside gains in major altcoins, lifting total crypto market value close to $2.45 trillion in one
CryptoFrontNews5h ago
XRP Today's News: Musk X Money Beta Released, Sparks On-Chain Integration Speculation
Elon Musk's X company has launched a beta version of the X Money payment system, allowing users to transfer and manage funds, sparking widespread discussion about XRP integration. Although there are no official plans for cryptocurrency integration at the moment, the market is generally optimistic. Analysts believe that XRP has design advantages for payments, especially with improved regulatory environments, making it more promising. However, the practicality of stablecoins is also under scrutiny. XRP is currently testing the $1.50 technical resistance level. If successfully broken through, it could trigger further gains.
MarketWhisper5h ago
Ripple's "dark road" connects to Wall Street's core—Is XRP's spring coming?
Ripple, through the acquisition of Hidden Road and gaining eligibility to participate in DTCC, has become part of the core clearing system of the U.S. financial markets. This marks that it is no longer an outsider to traditional finance and is integrating crypto assets with financial infrastructure. Despite challenges such as regulation and trust, Ripple's strategic positioning suggests that XRP could become a key asset for institutional-level settlements in the future.
PANews6h ago
