Ripple CTO David Schwartz and Craig Wright, posting under the pseudonym S. Tominaga recently, exchanged sharp arguments on X. Wright directly accused Schwartz of attempting to project control mechanisms, which he believes are characteristic of XRP, onto systems that lack centralized governance, such as Bitcoin.
The trigger for the dispute was Wright’s claim that a stable protocol does not require authority or coordination. David Schwartz called this “nonsense,” arguing that maintaining the status quo is not the absence of action but an active process.
Why Wright claims Schwartz misunderstands decentralization
According to Schwartz, if there are groups that want to change the system, they must be actively restrained from doing so, using the same mechanisms that could otherwise be used to implement changes.
HOT Stories
Ripple Vet Questions NYT Reporter’s Satoshi Hunt Proof
Midnight (NIGHT) Open Interest 100% Spike Could Be Followed, Ethereum’s (ETH) Only Possibility to Reach $3,000, XRP to Face Crucial Resistance Next Week: Crypto Market Review
Wright responded by accusing Schwartz of bias. He stated that Schwartz is basing his reasoning on the Ripple model, where changes are expected, coordinated and imposed, and is incorrectly presenting it as a universal standard.
According to Wright’s position, Schwartz is describing systems in which certain actors do in fact control the evolution of rules, and is projecting this experience onto protocols such as Bitcoin, which were specifically designed to eliminate the very possibility of such control.
Wright emphasized that in a fixed system, changes are not “prohibited” socially, they are simply not adopted by independent participants, as has been the case for decades with the TCP protocol.
While Schwartz sees immutability as the result of “overseers,” Wright insists on the “natural inertia” of the system, which requires nothing to function in a stable manner.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Exodus Wallet Expands XRP Ledger Support Through Ripple Partnership, Adds RLUSD
Exodus Movement announced a partnership with Ripple to enhance support for the XRP Ledger in its crypto wallet, allowing users to manage Ripple USD and send XRP assets seamlessly.
GateNews30m ago
Solana and Ripple's 'XRP' Posts Highlight $100M Wrapped XRP Integration
Solana's recent post about "XRP" led to Ripple's reply, influencing XRP's price. This comes amid the launch of wrapped XRP on Solana through Hex Trust and LayerZero, attracting significant liquidity, highlighting an evolving collaboration in the crypto space.
GateNews2h ago
XRP Rises 4% as Ripple Partnership and ETF Inflows Drive Recovery
XRP rose 4% to $1.41, boosted by Ripple's partnership with Kyobo Life and increasing institutional interest. Broader market gains and positive community engagement also contributed, though XRP remains 63% below its peak. Key support is at $1.38.
GateNews6h ago
XRP taps 44 million Rakuten users as Japan loyalty points turn into crypto
Rakuten Wallet has introduced XRP for trading and payments in Japan, allowing 44 million Rakuten Pay users to convert loyalty points into XRP, effectively integrating it into a major consumer commerce network. This move enhances everyday spending and expands XRP's reach in the market.
Cryptonews9h ago
Rakuten Pay Integrates XRP for 44 Million Japanese Users, Enables Payments at 5M+ Merchants
Rakuten Pay has integrated XRP, enabling 44 million users to spend the cryptocurrency at over 5 million merchants in Japan. This integration highlights a shift from trading cryptocurrencies to everyday payments, supported by Japan's favorable regulations and fintech infrastructure.
GateNews04-15 09:14
MoonPay Hints at Potential Ripple Collaboration With XRP-Themed Post
MoonPay's recent social media post featuring an XRP theme has sparked speculation about a potential partnership with Ripple. As both companies focus on enhancing cryptocurrency infrastructure, the implications of this possible collaboration, along with Ripple's initiatives in institutional finance, highlight a shift towards practical applications in the crypto space.
GateNews04-15 08:53
