When Extreme Fear Lingers: Crypto's Longest Pessimism Streak Since FTX, Despite Bitcoin's Surge

2026-01-12 07:49:10

The Crypto Fear & Greed Index has remained locked in ‘Extreme Fear’ territory for 14 consecutive days as of late December 2025, registering a score of 20. This represents the most prolonged period of deep market anxiety since the FTX collapse in November 2022—a striking reality considering Bitcoin (BTC) now trades around $91,640, roughly five times higher than during that catastrophic episode. The reading underscores a peculiar market dynamic: elevated prices coexisting with subdued investor sentiment.

The Paradox: All-Time Highs Coupled With Maximum Dread

Alternative.me’s Fear & Greed Index, which synthesizes volatility, trading volume, market dominance, and social media signals, has rarely stayed in extreme fear this long. During the FTX meltdown, the index experienced sharper swings as Bitcoin crashed from $20,000 to below $16,000 in days, triggering immediate panic and liquidity collapse. Today’s environment differs fundamentally.

BTC’s Current Position:

Price: $91.64K (+1.13% over 24h)
Market Cap: $1.83 trillion
24-Hour Volume: $648.95M
Volatility: Compressed yet anxiety persists

The broader cryptocurrency market trades sideways. While altcoin sectors show mixed signals—NFT tokens declined roughly 7.4% daily, yet AI and SocialFi baskets posted modest single-digit gains—the overall tone suggests selective rotation rather than broad risk appetite recovery.

Why Fear Grips Despite Rally Fundamentals?

Understanding what “greed meaning” represents in market psychology helps clarify today’s contradiction. The Fear & Greed Index measures not just price action but collective emotion. Extreme fear (0–24 range) signals potential capitulation, typically viewed as a contrarian buying signal. Yet it persisting for two weeks amid Bitcoin near all-time highs reveals deeper structural concerns.

Macro headwinds continue:

U.S. interest rates remain restrictive relative to post-2010 norms
Regulatory scrutiny intensifies across centralized exchanges and stablecoin protocols
Derivatives positioning shows caution: perpetual funding rates near flat or slightly negative, while open interest retreated from recent peaks

Spot market signals remain weak:

Trading volumes trail the euphoric 2024 ETF launch period
Bitcoin spot ETF flows exist but lack the conviction seen earlier in the cycle

Market Structure Reveals Lingering Distrust

The disconnect between price and sentiment stems from lingering institutional wariness. While leverage has compressed—reducing tail-risk scenarios—spot market participation remains tepid. Traders appear positioned for potential reversal rather than committed to continuation.

This 14-day extreme fear streak, longer than FTX’s initial shock, suggests market participants haven’t internalized recent rally fundamentals. The Fear & Greed Index methodology notes that extreme fear can signal oversold conditions and potential buying opportunity, yet sustained readings like this indicate genuine structural concerns rather than momentary panic.

Until spot volumes accelerate and funding rates flush out remaining shorts, this fear persistence may continue signaling a market wrestling with elevated valuations despite fundamental tailwinds.

BTC2,2%

This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.